Tierney Chandler left her quaint hometown and her seemingly ideal fiancé behind years ago, hoping to chase after her aspirations. Time has passed, but the town remains small, her dreams seem distant, and her ex-partner's perfection hasn't faded. Perhaps it's time for Tierney to reevaluate her unfulfilled dreams and consider going back home – or perhaps she needs to rediscover what she left behind...
Jack Elliott, a talented baker, has been turning his dreams into reality, one delicious pie at a time. Once upon a time, Tierney was a part of those dreams. But fate took a detour when his overly perfect cousin stepped in. Now, given a second opportunity, Jack is determined not to let history repeat itself. He's convinced that he can be the dream she's been waiting for all along. Can Jack convince Tierney to give their old connection another chance?