I Became an Immortal in the Mountains - Reviews

I Became an Immortal in the Mountains
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, so this whole subplot about the old man digging and digging while Gu Yuanqing is literally meditating into the same underground chamber — I actually laughed out loud. The dramatic irony here is *chef's kiss*. The old man spends every single day breaking rocks with spiritual energy strength, thinking he's on the verge of discovering something monumental, and Gu Yuanqing just… knows. He doesn't even gloat about it outwardly. He just thinks: "If he knew, what would he think?" And honestly, that's such a Gu Yuanqing move — internally amused, externally serene. The structure of discovery here is really clever too. Gu Yuanqing first finds the Heart Zen Unity Technique casually, then through his growing Mountain Observation ability *accidentally* discovers the entire underground armory/library. It's not a forced plot device — it flows naturally from the cultivation system the author built. The deeper he connects with the mountain, the more the mountain reveals itself. That cause-and-effect chain is tight. And the cliffhanger moment? He emerges from his meditation, finds the chamber, sees thirty+ cultivation methods including five Grandmaster-level ones, a secret sword beneath a portrait of some transcendent elder, weapons on racks, and then the chapter basically ends on him picking up the Wind and Rain Sword Manual. No big explosion, no revelation, just… the beginning of a whole new chapter of power accumulation. The author trusts us to be excited without spiking the adrenaline. Brilliant restraint. What also impressed me is how the subplot with Li Miaoxuan and Qin Baijun slots into the main plot without feeling disconnected. Her pregnancy, her explanation that she was caught off guard during a cultivation breakthrough — it's all tied to the wider world's involvement with him. She says she's here to "sever earthly ties" but clearly the imperial capital isn't letting go. That thread is gonna pull tight. The plot is building like a slow fire. No cheap twists, no manufactured drama. Just genuine cause-and-effect storytelling.
... Read More
Okay so here's what I keep coming back to: the entire setup with Gu Yuanqing being exiled to North Spring Mountain isn't just a classic 'cast out to train in isolation' trope. The author is playing something much cleverer. On the surface, it's a cultivation story where the MC gets dumped on a mountain, reads some books, breaks through to True Martial. Simple. But the real plot engine is this slow-burn reveal that the MOUNTAIN ITSELF is alive, or at least sentient, and Gu Yuanqing has this bizarre connection to it. Remember how the old man keeps digging? Three months in, four months in, still digging, five days without rest. That's not background flavor — that's a ticking clock. The author drops these tiny hints about the mountain being a former sword sect base, about a secret sword that points beyond Grandmaster, about why the imperial court stations guards year-round at only ONE entrance while the other three sides are cliffs. The soldiers themselves are confused about it: "Why are we stationed here?" even the young ones notice something is off. And then Gu Yuanqing does his Mountain Observation and literally FELS the mountain breathing, sensing spiritual energy growing stronger at its core. The breakthrough to True Martial happens not in some random cave but right when the mountain is about to achieve Spirit Nurturing status. Coincidence? The author clearly thinks not. The most satisfying plot beat for me was the acupoint deduction arc. He fails. Thirteen acupoints wrong. Tries again. Still wrong. Then he admits defeat — "It was truly overly ambitious of me to try to deduce the method..." — pivots to 108 acupoints, and BOOM, the True Martial Secret Cache forms with seven-colored light. That's not just a power-up scene; that's the plot saying the protagonist's way of thinking (his mortal-realm problem-solving) hits a wall, and he has to accept limits before actually advancing. The narrative is rewarding humility, not just genius. I also love that the eunuch Li subplot at the end connects the mountain mystery to palace intrigue. "Your esteemed father also holds the position of my Great Inter..." — the sentence cuts off mid-dialogue and it made me immediately want to read the next chapter. The author is weaving at least two plot threads together and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Qin Baijun because this man is a whole mood and also deeply unsettling in the best way. He hears a rumor — just a rumor from a eunuch — that an illegitimate Gu family son might have been involved with Li Miaoxuan, and his entire emotional state shifts from resentful to murderous in three seconds flat. 'How dare he, a mere illegitimate son, do such a thing?' Like bro, you're mad at someone you've never even met because they allegedly touched something you wanted? The jealousy is so raw it's almost funny if it weren't so dangerous. And then the跪 scene — he bows to the ground begging his grandfather to help him kill one person. One. Person. For love. That level of devotion is terrifying. It's the kind of thing that makes you simultaneously rooted for him and deeply worried for everyone around him. But honestly? Li Miaoxuan stole the scene. 'If I do not wish it, no one can force me, including Imperial Father himself.' A daughter telling the Emperor — her own father — that she won't be coerced, while visibly pregnant and in a forbidden garden under house arrest? That took guts. And her calmness throughout the entire conversation, even when he smashes the table? She's not bluffing. She's a Grandmaster. She means it. The power dynamic just flipped in that room and nobody realized it except her.
... Read More
The stakes in this batch went from barely visible to absolutely sky-high and I need a minute. Initially, the conflict is low-key—two people meeting at a mountain retreat, exchanging pleasantries, showing off cultivation techniques. But then you realize the entire encounter was built on a foundation of hidden danger. Li Miaoxuan is a Grandmaster who fell into someone's trap. Someone is actively hunting her. And she chose to reveal herself to Gu Yuanqing at the moment she needed to disappear. That's not casual—it's strategic. She couldn't trust anyone else, and the fact that she entrusted him with the Great Yi Illusionary Heaven Steps and the Heart Zen Unity Technique insights means she's betting her survival on him becoming stronger. The external stakes are clear: there's an enemy out there who trapped a Grandmaster, and Gu Yuanqing just got pulled into that war whether he likes it or not. But the internal stakes are where it actually hurts. He's sitting on a mountaintop processing the fact that the woman he shared tea and moonlight with is someone he once had intimacy with—and he has no memory of it. That's a conflict between his current self and a past self he can't access. And the worst part? She left him a breadcrumb trail instead of an explanation. "Come find me at Spirit Void Gate when you become a Grandmaster." She's telling him the destination but making him earn the journey. The tension here isn't just about will they meet again—it's about whether he'll be strong enough to survive finding her, and whether she'll still be there to be found.
... Read More
I need to talk about the old man. Not because he's important to Gu Yuanqing directly — he's not, apparently — but because the author has constructed this whole relationship dynamic WITHOUT any actual interaction between them. Gu Yuanqing watches him. The old man digs. That's it. But the amount of characterization packed into this silent observation is staggering. We learn the old man hasn't rested more than five days in months. We learn he's digging everywhere with no success. We learn he makes these odd sounds — "Aba aba!" — and the old woman beside him gestures wildly at him, and he silently suppresses his curiosity and goes back to chopping wood. Who IS this guy? Is he guarding the mountain? Searching for something? Punished like Gu Yuanqing? Or is he the reason Gu Yuanqing is here in the first place? The author treats Gu Yuanqing's observations of the old man with this weird intimacy. When Gu Yuanqing thinks about fighting him — "Do I have the strength to fight this old man now?" — the old man's movements literally STIFFEN and cold sweat breaks out on his forehead. They're connected at some level Gu Yuanqing hasn't even figured out yet. That moment gave me chills because it showed the old man isn't just a random NPC. He's reacting to Gu Yuanqing's thoughts FROM ACROSS THE MOUNTAIN. And then there's the emotional distance between them. Gu Yuanqing explicitly tells himself: "He and I have nothing to do with each other, why think about it?" But he keeps thinking about him. The author is building this slow-burn tension — two people on the same mountain who haven't spoken, can't speak, but are clearly orbiting each other in ways neither understands yet. Meanwhile, the court scene with Qin Baijun and Eunuch Li introduces a whole new set of relationships. The eunuch is careful, formal, almost subservient: "this humble servant shouldn't spread internal palace affairs." But Qin Baijun is clearly someone with connections — "Young Master Qin and Her Royal Highness are fellow disciples." There's a power dynamic here that feels real, political, dangerous. And the eunuch trailing off at the end? "Your esteemed father also holds the position of my Great Inter..." — the author refuses to let us see where that sentence goes, which makes me want to know EVERYTHING about Qin Baijun's family and why they're connected to both the Spirit Void Gate AND the imperial court.
... Read More
I want to talk about the pacing in these chapters because the author has this amazing ability to slow down time when it matters and let it fly when it doesn't. Take the meditation sequence during the storm. It starts with Gu Yuanqing lying on his chair, watching the sky. Then the thunderclap. Then the rain. And the prose just… opens up. The sentences get longer, more fluid, mimicking the expansion of his consciousness. First he feels the breeze on the ridge, then the raindrops hitting the mountain, then the water splashing in the courtyard, then — boom — he's inside the rain, inside the mountain, inside everything. And right when you're fully immersed in that transcendental experience, the author yanks you back: "Gu Yuanqing, feeling uncomfortable in his rain-soaked clothes, first withdrew his consciousness and returned to his room." That little detail about being uncomfortable in wet clothes is the funniest grounding moment. One second he's a god merging with the landscape, the next he's like "yeah okay, time to change into dry pajamas." I love it. Then there's the old man digging sequence, which the author deliberately places right after Gu Yuanqing discovers the chamber. Old man swings axe. Old man presses rock. Old man senses danger. Old man dismisses it. The chapter cuts between them like two threads of the same rope, one pulling upward and one pulling downward, not knowing they're connected. The Li Miaoxuan scene, meanwhile, is short and sharp — almost brutal in its efficiency. A few pages, a shattered teacup, a sword splitting a lake, and it's done. No lingering. It hits like a door slamming. The pacing between these three threads — cultivation breakthrough, political fallout, underground discovery — creates this constant forward momentum without ever feeling rushed. Each section earns its length. Nothing drags.
... Read More
I want to zoom in on the dialogue here because the author is doing something really interesting with how different characters' voices reveal information. The soldiers' conversation is the standout moment. A young soldier asks Uncle Qian: "Why are we stationed here year-round?" And Uncle Qian's response is perfect because it's simultaneously informative and dismissive. He gives the young soldier some lore — the mountain was once the North Spring Sword Sect's base, there's supposedly a secret sword pointing beyond Grandmaster — but then immediately shuts him down: "The imperial court has its reasons for making such arrangements. We just need to follow orders." That's not worldbuilding exposition. That's CHARACTER. Uncle Qian knows more than he's letting on, he's cautious, he's survived long enough in this system to understand that asking questions gets people killed. And the young soldier's follow-up — "do you know what crime that rich young master committed?" — shows he's either genuinely naive or deliberately fishing. Either way, the dialogue makes both characters feel real. Compare that to Eunuch Li's voice: "Originally, this humble servant shouldn't spread internal palace affairs." The self-referential language, the careful hedging, the immediate reminder of hierarchy — every word signals a man who has survived by knowing exactly when to speak and when to stay silent. And then he trails off mid-sentence when he starts to connect Qin Baijun's father to something sensitive. The author doesn't even need to finish the thought. The silence IS the dialogue. Gu Yuanqing's internal monologue is a different beast entirely. It's analytical, detached, occasionally self-deprecating: "I overlooked something... It seems I'll have to find another place to rest tonight." The humor in that line — treating his breakthrough like a minor inconvenience — reveals his personality better than any description could. He's not a brooding protagonist. He's a guy who just achieved True Martial and his biggest concern is that his bed collapsed and he needs a new place to sleep. The narration itself maintains this dry, understated tone throughout. Even the most dramatic moments — the Secret Cache forming, the seven-colored light, the mountain breathing — are described with restraint. The author trusts the reader to feel the weight without being told how to feel it. And that trust is earned.
... Read More
Can we talk about how these two talk to each other? On the surface, they're being polite guests at a mountain retreat. Underneath, they're basically sparring with words. Take this exchange: "You can call me Miaoxuan." "That name sounds familiar. Ah, yes, the Great Gan Dynasty's Eldest Princess..." "She is not me." Short, clipped, dismissive. But everything about it screams that she's testing him—does he remember? Does he figure it out? His response is equally layered: he laughs it off, says how could a dignified princess be here, but the narration tells us he has "a faint suspicion." He knows something is up but chooses the safe route. That's their whole dynamic in a nutshell—he pretends not to know, she pretends not to want him to figure it out. And the tea conversation later? Same thing. She talks about cultivation insights and he's supposed to just take it at face value, but the text says each of his remarks left her "in deep thought." She's not just teaching him—she's evaluating him. The most dialogue-rich moment is honestly the sword demonstration scene where she says "Acceptable" and he internally fumes that he expected more. Classic deflection. But the absolute peak is her final speech: "Grandmaster is just the beginning. The Great Gan Dynasty is still… too small!" That ellipsis though. She's saying so much but stopping herself. Her voice is so distinct from his—hers is measured, almost archaic in its precision, while his inner monologue is chaotic and emotional. You could tell who's who just from their speech patterns alone.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is genuinely masterful and I'm not sure the author gets enough credit for it. Let me explain what I mean. The text opens with Gu Yuanqing already deep in cultivation, forming sword intent, and then immediately pivots to: "Time flew by, and in the blink of an eye, several more months passed." Boom. Chapter. We skip the grind. We don't get thirty chapters of acupoint training. The author knows that the POINT isn't the repetition — it's the breakthrough. And by collapsing months into a single sentence, the author trains us to expect that time will move unevenly: slow when it matters, fast when it doesn't. Then comes the acupoint failure sequence, and the pacing SHIFTS. Suddenly we're inside a single night, second by second: Yuan Qi goes out of control, blood spills from his mouth, he re-examines his notes, makes a decision, adjusts, tries again. This is the same chapter structure as a thriller — compress the failure, expand the success. The reader experiences the frustration in real-time and then gets the release. What really impressed me though is how the author handles the transition between scale. We go from Gu Yuanqing's microscopic internal world (acupoints shimmering, Yuan Qi surging through meridians) to a macroscopic view of the entire mountain — the old man digging, the soldiers at the gate, the eunuch in the city. Each section is brief but grounded. No dragging. No filler. The mountain observation scenes act as chapter breaks that reset the reader's perspective without losing momentum. The cliffhanger structure is also interesting. The text doesn't end on a big action beat — it ends on the eunuch's half-finished sentence. Not an explosion. Not a revelation. Just... cut off mid-word. That's a bold pacing choice because it forces the reader to keep going purely out of intellectual curiosity rather than adrenaline. And honestly? It works. I needed to know what the eunuch was about to say. If I had one complaint, it's that the Heavenly Stem qi section at the end feels slightly rushed compared to the acupoint sequence. The epiphany comes almost too easily — he breathes, he observes, he collects qi, he smiles. It's functional but less textured than the earlier breakthrough. Still, given what the author is juggling across multiple plot threads, I won't complain too loudly.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or